Trouble between US and Saudis

Posted by Admin On Saturday, 26 October 2013 0 comments


Saudi Arabia is a crucial ally of the United States within the Middle East, but the long-time friendship between the two countries may now be under pressure.
Diplomatic sources say that Prince Bandar bin Sultan, Saudi’s intelligence chief, has been talking about his country making a “major shift” in its relationship with the US.
He has been quoted as sharply criticising US policies on Syria and Iran, as well as condemning its apparent lack of urgency on the Palestinian-Israeli track.
The deepening rift was acknowledged by US Secretary of State John Kerry. Speaking to reporters in London on Wednesday he said:
“We know that the Saudis were obviously disappointed that the Syria strike didn’t take place. It is our obligation to work closely with them – as I am doing … [but] I think there is a clear understanding in our relationship going forward, and I have great confidence that the United States and Saudi Arabia will continue to be the close and important friends and allies that we have been.”
But why is the kingdom apparently reassessing its relations with the US?
Going back to 2011, the Saudis were then angered by US criticism of the crackdown on anti-government protests in Bahrain. The government was also upset about the lack of US military action against Syria.
Saudi Arabia cancelled a speech at the UN General Assembly last month, and recently rejected a seat on the Security Council, citing “international double standards” on the Middle East as the reason.
The recent warming of relations between the US and Iran has also outraged the kingdom.
Saudi Arabia is seen as a pivotal anchor to US interests in the Middle East, and for decades the two have nutured ties primarily based on mutual oil and security interests.
Historians refer to a meeting between King Abdel Aziz and President Franklin D Roosevelt in 1945 as securing what is called “the special relationship”. That relationship continued throughout the Cold War with Saudi Arabia backing the US fight against communism.
Saudi Arabia’s 1973 oil embargo on the US put a strain on the relationship. But the kingdom later stepped in to fill the global oil shortage when war broke out between its neighbours Iraq and Iran –  a policy that was co-ordinated with the US.
More recently, the 9/11 attack, and the fact that many of the attackers were of Saudi origin, seriously damaged the kingdom’s image in the US. However, shared concerns about armed groups like al-Qaeda, and Iran’s regional ambitions, have provided what has been called a “renewed logic” for their strategic partnership.
The kingdom holds hundreds of billions of dollars in US treasury bonds; American oil and construction contractors have a massive presence in the kingdom; and Saudi also buys the bulk of its military equipment from the United States. The latest deal, posted on the Pentagon’s website just a few weeks ago, is worth $7bn.
So, is this a mere spat between the two countries, or the beginning of the end of a special relationship? And what will be the regional implications of a distance between them?
To discuss this, Inside Story, with presenter Mike Hanna, is joined by guests: Richard Murphy, a former US ambassador to Syria and Saudi Arabia; Hussein Shobokshi, a columnist at Asharq Alawsat, an international Arabic newspaper; and Greg Gause, professor of political science at the University of Vermont, who is also the author of Saudi Arabia in the New Middle East.
“I do think that there are real differences and opinions … on important issues like Syria and Egypt, [but] I do [also] think that the core of the relationship, which is always been about security in the Gulf region, is still there and still intact … Saudi is worried about the American talks with Iran, but I think that some of those fears are exaggerated, I don’t think that the United States is going to be turning over the keys of [the] Gulf security to Iran anytime soon.”
-  Greg Gause, a professor of political science at the University of Vermont

READ MORE

No Use No More: Is the CIA abandoning the TTP?

Posted by Admin On 0 comments
Latif Mehsud, second in command of the so called “Tehriq e Taliban Pakistan” was captured by the US forces a few days ago in Afghanistan, after Pakistan’s ISI tipped off US forces of the “top commander of the Afghan Taliban”. Little did they realise they had arrested a CIA asset.
Why the US arrested him is a sign that the TTP is crumbling.
It took many naive US soldiers by surprise when they realised that this dreaded militant was being escorted by officials of the Afghan intelligence and Afghan army, we were travelling in vehicles with Latif Mehsud at the time of his capture.
Upon interrogation by US forces, it was revealed that, their destination was the Indian High Commission in Jalalabad. Latif Mehsud is currently under arrest at Bagram Airbase awaiting further interrogation.
So why did US capture their ex-henchman? 
Well 2014 is around the corner…the endgame has arrived which means the end of the TTP. This outfit was considered a strategic asset of the CIA inside Pakistan, but as the US prepares to withdraw its forces from Afghanistan, the decision of the CIA is to obliterate the TTP rather than risk this group going rogue and his arrest is a clear indication of that.
Those of you who don’t know, US forces REFUSED on many occasions to attack TTP camps inside Afghanistan because the TTP had not attacked US forces – in fact, soon after the Malala incident (where TTP operatives had come from Afghanistan), the US refused to arrest known militants associated with the attack on her.
Soon after Mehsud’s arrest, Karzai unleashed his anger over US forces in public for their unilateral action.
Karzai and India want to keep TTP intact post-US withdrawal. The US on the other hand seems to have opposed that for various reasons.
Conclusion:
India is desperately trying to keep Pakistan bleeding, but it looks like India’s love affair with Afghanistan has come to a grinding halt.
India’s Afghanistan project has miserably failed – it had put its faith in the UNOCOL elected Afghanistan government (City Hall of Kabul in reality) yet this fake government was not able to put its writ on any part of Afghanistan.
In fact, the central government today is weaker than it was 5 years ago!
Post 2014 will be Pakistan’s retribution phase, which has already started in Kashmir.
Many within Pakistan are openly calling for support to Khalistan and the Northeast Separatists coupled with cooperation from Dravida Nadu separatists in South India.
Indian think tanks are in panic mode at the moment – their crimes inside Pakistan have been Himalayan in nature but retribution is bound to be higher in quantity as well as in quality.
Game on India…the ball is in our court now. Enjoy the ride!
READ MORE

With its $ 17 trillion debt, can US afford to give aid?

Posted by Admin On Thursday, 24 October 2013 0 comments
As the national debt tops $17 trillion — thanks to the newly sealed debt-ceiling agreement — America’s costly foreign aid tab is back in the crosshairs.
The federal government in fiscal 2012 spent about $21 billion on non-military foreign assistance and was on track to spend roughly the same in 2013, according to federal records. As Washington enters the new fiscal year, another huge chunk of aid is being released — the Associated Press reported over the weekend that the U.S. is planning to free up more than $1.6 billion in aid to Pakistan following a lengthy hiatus.
Daniel Markey, a senior fellow with the Council on Foreign Relations, suggested Monday that the aid decision was premature. He told FoxNews.com Live that the U.S. should at least be changing the way that money is used.
“We haven’t gotten a lot out of Pakistan … and we’ve spent billions and billions of dollars,” Markey said Monday.
He said new leadership in Pakistan offers a reason to keep trying “but we should be very careful.”
The aid had been on ice after a major breakdown in U.S.-Pakistan relations. Pakistan lashed out at the U.S. over the 2011 raid on Usama bin Laden’s compound. U.S. lawmakers were similarly outraged after Pakistan imprisoned a doctor alleged to have helped the CIA in tracking bin Laden.
Ties continued to fray after the U.S. mistakenly fired on and killed two dozen Pakistani soldiers.
But after a long pause, and an election in Pakistan, both sides are trying to rebuild their relationship.
Newly elected Pakistani Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif arrived in the U.S. on Sunday, for the first visit by a Pakistani head of state since 2008, and met with Secretary of State John Kerry. In a statement, the State Department said they “continued the robust dialogue on our shared goal of a stable, secure and prosperous Pakistan.” The statement stressed the importance of “continued counterterrorism cooperation.”
Aid to Pakistan over the years has been channeled to everything from health to education to economic development.
But it is Pakistan’s role in counterterrorism operations that has made the U.S. so reluctant to cut ties with the country altogether. Despite suspicion running high between the two governments — and concerns that some Pakistani officials are taking U.S. money with one hand and helping America’s enemies with the other — many in Washington see the partnership as one of necessity.
Markey, author of “No Exit from Pakistan: America’s Tortured Relationship with Islamabad,” said the U.S. still needs the supply lines in and out of Afghanistan as that war winds down. But he said the U.S. should be “skeptical.”
The battle over how much to give to which countries has been escalating in Washington, and Republicans have made it a perennial target as they seek additional savings.
House Republicans proposed a nearly $6 billion cut to foreign aid in their fiscal 2014 budget proposal.
Congress has not yet passed a full-year budget — the latest agreement to end the partial government shutdown resulted in a bill to fund the government for just three months. Lawmakers are now seeking a broader agreement to both fund the government and cut the deficit.
Amid the resumption of aid to Pakistan, the Obama administration recently decided to put some aid to Egypt on hold. The decision came after then-President Mohammed Morsi was overthrow.
READ MORE

War is business

Posted by Admin On 0 comments
Disaster capitalism on the battlefield and in the boardroom
There is a new normal in America: our government may shut down, but our wars continue.  Congress may not be able to pass a budget, but the U.S. military can still launch commando raids in Libya and Somalia, the Afghan War can still be prosecuted, Italy can be garrisoned by American troops (putting the “empire” back in Rome), Africa can be used as an imperial playground (as in the late nineteenth century “scramble for Africa,” but with the U.S. and China doing the scrambling this time around), and the military-industrial complex can still dominate the world’s arms trade.
In the halls of Congress and the Pentagon, it’s business as usual, if your definition of “business” is the power and profits you get from constantly preparing for and prosecuting wars around the world.  “War is a racket,” General Smedley Butler famously declared in 1935, and even now it’s hard to disagree with a man who had two Congressional Medals of Honor to his credit and was intimately familiar with American imperialism.
War Is Politics, Right?
Once upon a time, as a serving officer in the U.S. Air Force, I was taught that Carl von Clausewitz had defined war as a continuation of politics by other means.  This definition is, in fact, a simplification of his classic and complex book, On War, written after his experiences fighting Napoleon in the early nineteenth century.
The idea of war as a continuation of politics is both moderately interesting and dangerously misleading: interesting because it connects war to political processes and suggests that they should be fought for political goals; misleading because it suggests that war is essentially rational and so controllable.  The fault here is not Clausewitz’s, but the American military’s for misreading and oversimplifying him.
Perhaps another “Carl” might lend a hand when it comes to helping Americans understand what war is really all about.  I’m referring to Karl Marx, who admired Clausewitz, notably for his idea that combat is to war what a cash payment is to commerce.  However seldom combat (or such payments) may happen, they are the culmination and so the ultimate arbiters of the process.
War, in other words, is settled by killing, a bloody transaction that echoes the exploitative exchanges of capitalism.  Marx found this idea to be both suggestive and pregnant with meaning. So should we all.
Following Marx, Americans ought to think about war not just as an extreme exercise of politics, but also as a continuation of exploitative commerce by other means.  Combat as commerce: there’s more in that than simple alliteration.
In the history of war, such commercial transactions took many forms, whether as territory conquered, spoils carted away, raw materials appropriated, or market share gained.  Consider American wars.  The War of 1812 is sometimes portrayed as a minor dust-up with Britain, involving the temporary occupation and burning of our capital, but it really was about crushing Indians on the frontier and grabbing their land.  The Mexican-American War was another land grab, this time for the benefit of slaveholders.  The Spanish-American War was a land grab for those seeking an American empire overseas, while World War I was for making the world “safe for democracy” — and for American business interests globally.
Even World War II, a war necessary to stop Hitler and Imperial Japan, witnessed the emergence of the U.S. as the arsenal of democracy, the world’s dominant power, and the new imperial stand-in for a bankrupt British Empire.
Korea?  Vietnam?  Lots of profit for the military-industrial complex and plenty of power for the Pentagon establishment.  Iraq, the Middle East, current adventures in Africa?  Oil, markets, natural resources, global dominance.
In societal calamities like war, there will always be winners and losers.  But the clearest winners are often companies like Boeing and Dow Chemical, which provided B-52 bombers and Agent Orange, respectively, to the U.S. military in Vietnam.  Such “arms merchants” — an older, more honest term than today’s “defense contractor” — don’t have to pursue the hard sell, not when war and preparations for it have become so permanently, inseparably intertwined with the American economy, foreign policy, and our nation’s identity as a rugged land of “warriors” and “heroes” (more on that in a moment).
War as Disaster Capitalism
Consider one more definition of war: not as politics or even as commerce, but as societal catastrophe.  Thinking this way, we can apply Naomi Klein’s concepts of the “shock doctrine” and “disaster capitalism” to it.  When such disasters occur, there are always those who seek to turn a profit.
Most Americans are, however, discouraged from thinking about war this way thanks to the power of what we call “patriotism” or, at an extreme, “superpatriotism” when it applies to us, and the significantly more negative “nationalism” or “ultra-nationalism” when it appears in other countries.  During wars, we’re told to “support our troops,” to wave the flag, to put country first, to respect the patriotic ideal of selfless service and redemptive sacrifice (even if all but 1% of us are never expected to serve or sacrifice).
We’re discouraged from reflecting on the uncomfortable fact that, as “our” troops sacrifice and suffer, others in society are profiting big time.  Such thoughts are considered unseemly and unpatriotic.  Pay no attention to the war profiteers, who pass as perfectly respectable companies.  After all, any price is worth paying (or profits worth offering up) to contain the enemy — not so long ago, the red menace, but in the twenty-first century, the murderous terrorist.
Forever war is forever profitable.  Think of the Lockheed Martins of the world.  In their commerce with the Pentagon, as well as the militaries of other nations, they ultimately seek cash payment for their weapons and a world in which such weaponry will be eternally needed.  In the pursuit of security or victory, political leaders willingly pay their price.
Call it a Clausewitzian/Marxian feedback loop or the dialectic of Carl and Karl.  It also represents the eternal marriage of combat and commerce.  If it doesn’t catch all of what war is about, it should at least remind us of the degree to which war as disaster capitalism is driven by profit and power.
For a synthesis, we need only turn from Carl or Karl to Cal — President Calvin Coolidge, that is.  “The business of America is business,” he declared in the Roaring Twenties.  Almost a century later, the business of America is war, even if today’s presidents are too polite to mention that the business is booming.
America’s War Heroes as Commodities
Many young people today are, in fact, looking for a release from consumerism.  In seeking new identities, quite a few turn to the military.  And it provides.  Recruits are hailed as warriors and warfighters, as heroes, and not just within the military either, but by society at large.
Yet in joining the military and being celebrated for that act, our troops paradoxically become yet another commodity, another consumable of the state.  Indeed, they become consumed by war and its violence.  Their compensation?  To be packaged and marketed as the heroes of our militarized moment. Steven Gardiner, a cultural anthropologist and U.S. Army veteran, has written eloquently about what he calls the “heroic masochism” of militarized settings and their allure for America’s youth.  Put succinctly, in seeking to escape a consumerism that has lost its meaning and find a release from dead-end jobs, many volunteers are transformed into celebrants of violence, seekers and givers of pain, a harsh reality Americans ignore as long as that violence is acted out overseas against our enemies and local populations.
Such “heroic” identities, tied so closely to violence in war, often prove poorly suited to peacetime settings.  Frustration and demoralization devolve into domestic violence and suicide.  In an American society with ever fewer meaningful peacetime jobs, exhibiting greater and greater polarization of wealth and opportunity, the decisions of some veterans to turn to or return to mind-numbing drugs of various sorts and soul-stirring violence is tragically predictable.  That it stems from their exploitative commodification as so many heroic inflictors of violence in our name is a reality most Americans are content to forget.
You May Not Be Interested in War, but War Is Interested in You
As Russian revolutionary Leon Trotsky pithily observed, “You may not be interested in war, but war is interested in you.”  If war is combat and commerce, calamity and commodity, it cannot be left to our political leaders alone — and certainly not to our generals.  When it comes to war, however far from it we may seem to be, we’re all in our own ways customers and consumers.  Some pay a high price.  Many pay a little.  A few gain a lot.  Keep an eye on those few and you’ll end up with a keener appreciation of what war is actually all about.
No wonder our leaders tell us not to worry our little heads about our wars — just support those troops, go shopping, and keep waving that flag.  If patriotism is famously the last refuge of the scoundrel, it’s also the first recourse of those seeking to mobilize customers for the latest bloodletting exercise in combat as commerce.
Just remember: in the grand bargain that is war, it’s their product and their profit.  And that’s no bargain for America, or for that matter for the world.
BY WILLIAM J. ASTORE
SALON NEWS
READ MORE

Iran Russia hold talks to boost air defense

Posted by Admin On 0 comments
The commander of the Khatam-ol-Anbiya Air Defense Base held talks on air defense systems with Russian Air Force Commander in Chief Lieutenant General Viktor Bondarev in Tehran on Sunday.
“In the meeting, we held talks with the Russian Air Force commander about issues related to air defense and radar systems,” Brigadier General Farzad Esmaeili told a press conference.
He also said that they had exchanged views about air defense techniques and missile systems.
In addition, the general said that Tehran and Moscow believed that the more the two countries’ defense doctrines were aligned, the more the regional stability was promoted.
Elsewhere in his remarks, Esmaeili announced that Iranian armed forces had staged a major air defense military exercise, entitled Defenders of the Skies of Velayat 5, from October 5 to 9 over an area covering about 700,000 square kilometers in northwestern and southwestern Iran.
The Russian Air Force commander also met with the commander of the Iranian Air Force, Brigadier General Shahsaffi, on the same day.
READ MORE

Japan to consider weapon export

Posted by Admin On 0 comments
Japan plans to review its self-imposed ban on weapons exports, according to a draft of the country’s new security strategy, a proposal that could unnerve China and South Korea.
Resentment over Japan’s wartime aggression still runs deep in both countries and any decision by Japan to become more active militarily is likely to cause tension.
Beijing and Seoul have long-running territorial disputes with Tokyo over different sets of tiny islets.
The draft, based on recommendations by a panel of security experts, is set to be fine-tuned into the final version by December and the direction of the strategy will be reflected in Japan’s new defence guidelines, due also by the end of the year.
Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe took office in December for a rare second term, pledging to bolster the military to cope with what Japan sees as an increasingly threatening security environment including an assertive China and an unpredictable North Korea.
Pacifism by law
Abe also aims to lift the constraints placed by Japan’s post-war pacifist constitution on its military.
Article 9 of the constitution, drafted by occupying US forces after the country’s defeat in world war two, renounces the right to wage war and, if taken literally, rules out the very notion of a standing army.
Japan “will contribute more actively than before to securing the world’s peace, stability and prosperity, from the standpoint of active pacifism based on the principle of international cooperation,” the draft said.
It said Japan’s decades-old ban on weapons export needs to be revised, a move that would reinvigorate Japan’s struggling defence industry.
Japan in 1967 drew up “three principles” on arms exports, banning sales to countries with communist governments or that are involved in international conflicts or subject to United Nations sanctions.
But the rules eventually became almost a blanket ban on arms exports and on the development and production of weapons with countries other than the United States, making it difficult for Japanese defence contractors to drive down costs and keep up with cutting-edge arms technology.
Defence contractors that could benefit from any loosening of the ban include Mitsubishi and Kawasaki.
READ MORE

At the Primordial Stage

Posted by Admin On 0 comments

Kerry and Nawaz Sharif MeetingThree weeks ago Pakistan’s Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif shook hands with Obama, Manmohan Singh, and other leaders of the World at the United Nations General Assembly Summit. The timing of this meeting could not have been at a more crucial stage for the newly elected government, occupied with internal economic and security challenges, forming policies, setting objectives, hoping to forge sustainable alliances. What will Sharif press forward this year, reaping his third opportunity at the Prime seat? We want to talk about drones, the Taliban, Kashmir, our economic crises; we want good ties with India but we will not let go of the past grievances. Kashmir needs to be addressed: stressed our Prime Minister.
Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and Nawaz Sharif shook hands in New York, 29 September 2013, and agreed to find effective means to restore the ceasefire on the Line of Control. Both representatives expressed their concerns. Manmohan wanted the Mumbai attacks perpetrators brought to justice, Sharif agreed. A set of preconditions to a meeting in the future was conveyed to his Pakistani counterpart. But given the new rise of Modi, anti-Pakistan rhetoric in mainstream Indian media, and a foreign policy attacking Pakistan’s intentions towards her neighbor, Singh even went against his own party’s wishes to make this contact in New York.
Manmohan might not be so powerful anymore. Little support from his party and an aggressive BJP, summed with an anti Pakistan sentiment fueled by small border disturbances and the blame game, it is obvious that Pakistan and India have experienced patches greener than this. Back home as the Peshawar church bomb blasts, the day before PM Sharif was to address the Nations of the World, claimed around 81 lives, it would have made sense to observe a moment of silence and spend more time on our massive security concerns perhaps. Or to grieve the mistakes and shortfalls in safeguarding the very basic rights a human being, by virtue of being alive, is entitled to.
The previous government spent its tenure criticizing the US unilateral policies, the infringement upon our sovereignty. Drone attacks, from a local phenomenon escalated to an issue of international importance. But while Hinna Rabbani Khar spoke with flair and charm in front of cameras, her passion seemed to freeze, turn to ice as she sat in the United Nations Security Council for two years, without speaking a word. While rallies, protests and documentaries press upon this issue, unless the establishment, the representatives, choose to utilize their voices, and to raise their concerns on international forums, it is highly unlikely to move forward.
The grievances of the previous government have been passed on, and need to be addressed. When Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif represents his nation at the United Nations platform, should he be asking for trade or aid? Should he be mourning the injustice and lack of control prevalent in his country today, or should he be talking about a way forward? These questions are tricky, and why can’t Pakistan do both? It is no secret that we need help. Our neighbors look at us with suspicion, while we take the brunt of a war for the 33rd year in a row. Millions of refugees burden the economy; illegal trade routes through India, Iran and Afghanistan threaten security and make us more vulnerable.
As if security concerns hadn’t already hit the ceiling, our energy shortage has reached the crisis situation since 2007. As a result textile and other industries, very efficient on their own, are losing business worth US$ 1 billion each year to Bangladesh and Sri Lanka, because they just cannot produce without gas and electricity. We need to be able to provide our industry with fuel to improve our Balance of Trade and pump money into the system; before there is barely any Capital left in Pakistan. So when Nawaz Shairf says we need ‘Trade not Aid’ his words perhaps resonate well with the masses, who haven’t seen dollars pumping bringing any long term benefits. Aid remains at the disposal of the few, to decide where spending can bring immediate results.
Today the Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh met Vladimir Putin, Russian President, in Moscow. His trip has strengthened their understanding, and together they aim to fight terrorism, and other threats both countries face in the future. There is a hot debate currently trending in India: whether these statements from Putin were an indirect warning to Pakistan. For now nothing can be said for sure. Singh’s next stop is Beijing. After restricted talks with Chinese Premier Li Keqiang, and delegation level talks, both overseeing the inking of a slew of agreements; a meeting for India-China CEOs Forum is planned followed by a lunch banquet hosted by Premier Li. The main theme between India and China is business, boosting trade and fueling their individual economies. Simultaneously a mutual aerial defense pact between Russia and Iran is underway.
On the other hand, Nawaz Sharif’s destination remains the West. Yesterday John Kerry and the Premier focused on “strengthening Pak-US ties”. Ties for what: security, mutual defense, trade, better border management, joint exercises to build trust between on the Pak-Afghan border, or a nuclear deal to help Pakistan overcome the energy crisis and come to par with India next door? We don’t know yet. But like most of Pakistan’s interactions with foreign state representatives, this too sounds less goal-oriented. Sharif stressed on trade more than sovereignty issues. While that strategy can be deemed more dignified, it is hardly effective when all of Pakistan celebrates possible resumption of $1.6 billion aid, previously blocked due to trust issues. So while Asian nations build alliances based on tangible goals, and mutual assistance, it seems like Pakistan is hoping to be taken under a powerful wing.
TACSTRAT ANALYSIS
READ MORE

All eyes on god’s gold

Posted by Admin On 0 comments
India’s central bank, the Reserve Bank of India, kicked up a storm after it asked select “rich” temples of India to declare the value of their gold holdings. Temple boards, which […]India’s central bank, the Reserve Bank of India, kicked up a storm after it asked select “rich” temples of India to declare the value of their gold holdings.
Temple boards, which manage temples in India, rejected the RBI’s request to furnish gold stock details while Hindu religious outfits threatened to launch a nation-wide protest on behalf of these temples.
The RBI is understood to have stepped back.
“We [the Hindu Parliament] had threatened to stage nation-wide protests on behalf of the temples against RBI’s stand. The temples are under no obligation to reveal any details to any government body. We have been openly saying that they are touching fire (with this move),” said Rahul Easwar, Secretary, Hindu Parliament, an outfit that has represented Hindu temples at various forums.
Speaking to Al Jazeera, Easwar, the grandson of the supreme priest of India’s famous Sabarimala temple, said: “The RBI has informed the Travancore Devaswom Board, which manages a thousand plus temples, including the Sabarimala hill shrine, that its earlier letter [seeking details about gold holdings] can be ignored.”
While the RBI officials were unavailable for any comments, unofficial sources confirm that an oral communication to this effect has issued to the temples, who are now demanding a written document as proof.
Who owns the gold lying idle in the vaults of some of India’s rich temples? Should India use this treasure trove to tide over its current economic crisis?
India’s Fort Knox
The US Bullion Depository Fort Knox’s website says it has 147.3 million ounces (4,603 tonnes) of gold holdings currently. Interestingly, according to the World Gold Council estimates, temples in India have about 2,000 tonnes of gold ($84 bn) and the Reserve Bank of India (RBI, June 2013 statistics) reported holdings of 557.7 tonnes of gold.
Statistics state that Indian temples possess the equivalent of half of what Fort Knox holds.
In 2011, gold worth $20bn was discovered in subterranean vaults at the centuries-old Sree Padmanabhaswamy Temple, in the southern state of Kerala.
According to unconfirmed figures, Tirupati Temple, which receives 10kg of gold every week, alone holds about 200 tonnes of gold in its vaults.
Most of the temple gold is donated by devotees either seeking blessings or favours of their revered gods and goddesses.
The temple boards are convinced that the RBI does not have any right over either the gold or the related accounts.
Lieutenant-Colonel Bhuvanendran Nair (retd), the executive officer of Sree Padmanabhaswamy Temple said, “.. .all this gold has been given to the temple by the devotees. It is the wealth of the temples. The currency that we get is used to run the temple, pay salaries and pensions of the priests, give food to the poor and other such activities. No one gives us [temples'] money. How else will we function? What will this little gold do to our economy and nation? We have taken a stand to not share any details with the RBI.”
India, soaking up a third of the world’s gold supply every year, is the world’s biggest importer of the yellow metal.
It imports billions of dollars worth gold every year and sends its own currency [the rupee, which has lesser purchasing power than the US dollar] overseas.
This disrupts the balance of money entering and leaving its economy. Thus, economists explain, the Indian rupee’s value has been depreciating.
Gold’s positive role
In the current scenario it is good to understand the positive role that gold plays in the global economy. Ecnomic value generated by the industry has a direct impact on the economies where gold production or consumption takes place.
Economists further elaborate, that owing to various socio-economic conditions as well as regulations, the 1.24 billion Indians equate stocks of the precious metal with savings and security even today.
For instance, the “not-so-well-off” part of the society finds it convenient to mortgage their gold savings with local money lenders than raising loans.
As a result, India’s import-export imbalance [or current-account deficit, CAD] in the first quarter of the current financial year was 4.9 percent of GDP ($21.8bn), double of what is considered to be “comfortable”.
Strikingly, gold, a non-essential import item, accounts for 80 percent of the country’s CAD.
Questioning the RBI’s move, India’s main opposition party feels that the apex body, in consultation with the central government, sought to check the rupee’s fall by buying these gold holdings from temples.
So, did the government retrace steps fearing protests just before the upcoming general elections in 2014?
“Nobody has the right to touch the temple gold. It belongs to the God and the devotees. Moreover, this Congress government did not leave coal [referring to the coal-blocks allocation scam], why will they not touch gold? Is an economic debate on behalf of a failed government just?” questioned Nirmala Sitaraman, National Spokesperson for Bharatiya Janata Party, India’s largest opposition party, which is often referred to as the political voice of the Hindu religious movements.
It is difficult convincing the devotees as well. Businessmen are known to donate huge amounts of gold belongings at various temples to win favours in business deals.
“I am honest to my God. I go and donate five percent of my profits from every deal to Lord Tirupati. And I pay taxes to the Indian government which is more than 35 percent. Why does the government want the God’s share too?” one such businessman, who did not want to be named, said.
Different school of thought
While the RBI has on records said that it sought all the information as a mere statistical measure, a different school of thought supports the use of temple gold to save India’s economy.
Som Prakash Yadav, president, Vishwa Drama Peetha, a Hindu organisation that claims to be propagating the essence of right knowledge, said: “I agree with the RBI completely. Our religion and scriptures never asked anyone to hoard gold. Kindly do not misinterpret religion.
“I do not understand why we import gold, will we die without it? India is a reservoir of gold; we have gold in our houses and at temples. But where is the use utility of this yellow metal? We are merely hoarding gold in the name of religion, God, rituals and sentiments. We are punishing the global economy with this wrong perspective.”
Houseds of worship such as the Shree Siddhivinayak Ganpati temple of India’s financial capital, Mumbai, and the Tirupati temple have already deposited gold into banks and are drawing interest on the same.
Bankers and lawyers feel there is no need to worry or create panic. For one thing, it is beyond the jurisdiction of the RBI to dictate terms to the temples.
For another since the ownership of the gold lies with temple trust boards, the RBI cannot “use” it.
“We need to understand that this gold cannot come to the RBI just like that. RBI cannot dictate things to the temples. The rules, regulations and the governing bodies are different. So, what is the problem? The temples can deposit their gold with the banks and earn interest. Moreover, the RBI cannot use this gold since the ownership lies elsewhere. My suggestion is to introduce gold bonds that temples can buy in place of keeping physical gold. Allow them to encash it at the market rate whenever they want to,” Jyoti Prakash Gadia, managing Director of Resurgent India, an investment bank, said.
P Chidambadam, India’s finance minister, has said at many forums that India aims to better its balance of imports and exports by cutting down the inflow of gold and silver into the country. How it will meet this goal is a question that remains unanswered given the gold obsession, reluctant rich temples, threats by Hindu outfits, sluggish growth and depreciating rupee.
Interestingly, the Indian law states that temple deities are perpetual minors and can have legal representation in courts through trustees or temple priests.
The learned argue: How can you take away the wealth of a minor without the consent of his/her guardian?
READ MORE

Obama positive about deal with Iran

Posted by Admin On Tuesday, 22 October 2013 0 comments
US President Barack Obama and Iranian President Hassan Rouhani spoke by telephone Friday, the first conversation between American and Iranian presidents in more than 30 years. The exchange could reflect a major step in resolving global concerns over Iran’s nuclear program.
Obama told reporters at the White House that he had a constructive conversation with the Iranian leader.
“While there will surely be important obstacles to moving forward and success is by no means guaranteed, I believe we can reach a comprehensive solution,” he said.
Obama said he and Rouhani have directed their teams to work quickly to pursue an agreement. He said the US will coordinate closely with its allies — including Israel, which considers an Iranian nuclear weapon capability to be an existential threat.
The fact that it had been so long since American and Iranian presidents had traded words reflected the “deep mistrust between our countries,” Obama said. But he added that it also indicated the opportunity for moving forward.
“I do believe there is a basis for a resolution,” he said.
The conversation came hours after Rouhani, wrapping up a trip to the US, called the United States a “great” nation, a sharp reversal from his predecessors that buoyed hopes that the two governments can stop the escalation of tensions.
“I want it to be the case that this trip will be a first step, and a beginning for better and constructive relations with countries of the world as well as a first step for a better relationship between the two great nations of Iran and the United States of America,” Rouhani told a news conference at a hotel near UN headquarters.
READ MORE

Considering the possibility of a de-Americanised world

Posted by Admin On 0 comments
BEIJING: As U.S. politicians of both political parties are still shuffling back and forth between the White House and the Capitol Hill without striking a viable deal to bring normality to the body politic they brag about, it is perhaps a good time for the befuddled world to start considering building a de-Americanized world.
Emerging from the bloodshed of the Second World War as the world’s most powerful nation, the United States has since then been trying to build a global empire by imposing a postwar world order, fueling recovery in Europe, and encouraging regime-change in nations that it deems hardly Washington-friendly.
With its seemingly unrivaled economic and military might, the United States has declared that it has vital national interests to protect in nearly every corner of the globe, and been habituated to meddling in the business of other countries and regions far away from its shores.
Meanwhile, the U.S. government has gone to all lengths to appear before the world as the one that claims the moral high ground, yet covertly doing things that are as audacious as torturing prisoners of war, slaying civilians in drone attacks, and spying on world leaders.
Under what is known as the Pax-Americana, we fail to see a world where the United States is helping to defuse violence and conflicts, reduce poor and displaced population, and bring about real, lasting peace.
Moreover, instead of honoring its duties as a responsible leading power, a self-serving Washington has abused its superpower status and introduced even more chaos into the world by shifting financial risks overseas, instigating regional tensions amid territorial disputes, and fighting unwarranted wars under the cover of outright lies.
As a result, the world is still crawling its way out of an economic disaster thanks to the voracious Wall Street elites, while bombings and killings have become virtually daily routines in Iraq years after Washington claimed it has liberated its people from tyrannical rule.
Most recently, the cyclical stagnation in Washington for a viable bipartisan solution over a federal budget and an approval for raising debt ceiling has again left many nations’ tremendous dollar assets in jeopardy and the international community highly agonized.
Such alarming days when the destinies of others are in the hands of a hypocritical nation have to be terminated, and a new world order should be put in place, according to which all nations, big or small, poor or rich, can have their key interests respected and protected on an equal footing.
To that end, several corner stones should be laid to underpin a de-Americanized world.
For starters, all nations need to hew to the basic principles of the international law, including respect for sovereignty, and keeping hands off domestic affairs of others.
Furthermore, the authority of the United Nations in handling global hotspot issues has to be recognized. That means no one has the right to wage any form of military action against others without a UN mandate.
Apart from that, the world’s financial system also has to embrace some substantial reforms.
The developing and emerging market economies need to have more say in major international financial institutions including the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund, so that they could better reflect the transformations of the global economic and political landscape.
What may also be included as a key part of an effective reform is the introduction of a new international reserve currency that is to be created to replace the dominant U.S. dollar, so that the international community could permanently stay away from the spillover of the intensifying domestic political turmoil in the United States.
Of course, the purpose of promoting these changes is not to completely toss the United States aside, which is also impossible. Rather, it is to encourage Washington to play a much more constructive role in addressing global affairs.
And among all options, it is suggested that the beltway politicians first begin with ending the pernicious impasse.
By Liu Chang
Xinhua News
READ MORE
The Supreme Court of Pakistan on Monday rejected Shahrukh Jatoi's appeal to remove sections of anti-terrorism laws in the Shahzeb Khan's murder case. A two-member bench comprising Justice Anwar Zaheer Jamali and Justice Sarmad Usmani announced the decision at Supreme Court's Karachi registry. It was stated in the petition that the incident took place due to personal dispute, thus the case did not come under anti-terrorism section. 

The court expressed dissatisfaction and upheld decision of the Sindh High Court. An anti-terrorism court had handed death sentences to Shahrukh Jatoi and Siraj Talpur. In the final charge-sheet submitted to the ATC, the police investigator had charged the main accused and co-accused under Section 302 of the Pakistan Penal Code (PPC) and under Section 7 of the anti-terrorism act (ATA) 1997.

However, on September 9, Shahzeb Khan's parents decided to pardon those convicted of their son's murder in the 'name of Allah.' On December 25 last year, Shahzeb Khan was gunned down in Karachi by Shahrukh Jatoi, who was accompanied by his friends Siraj and Sajjad Talpur. The young men had a fight after Talpur's servant, Ghulam Murtaza Lashari, teased Khan's sister.

After Khan's killing, youths and civil society groups had taken to the streets in Karachi and other cities to highlight the murder, prompting the Supreme Court to take suo moto notice 10 days after the murder. After prolonged hearings of the case in the Supreme Court and an anti-terrorism court in Karachi, the ATC finally delivered its verdict in June. It awarded the death penalty to Jatoi and Siraj Talpur, another prime accused in the case, and life imprisonment to Sajjad Talpur and Murtaza Lashari.
Copyright News Network International, 2013
READ MORE

While its people die of hunger, India aims for Mars

Posted by Admin On 0 comments

ISRO
India’s Mangalyaan spacecraft is built in India’s state-of-the-art construction facility in Banglalore
The upcoming launch of a spacecraft to Mars by India is likely to stoke the fires of a burgeoning Asian space race.
The Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) is making its final preparations to send an orbiter to the Red Planet.
The principal aim is to test out India’s space technology to see if this emerging space-faring nation is capable of interplanetary missions.
The spacecraft will also collect scientific information about the planet’s atmosphere and surface.
The Mangalyaan probe was to have been launched as early as 28 October, but rough weather in the Pacific forced officials to delay the launch by a week. The unmanned mission has a launch window lasting until 19 November.
If the mission succeeds, ISRO will become only the fourth space agency, after those in the US, Europe and Russia to have successfully sent a spacecraft to Mars.
According to Pallava Bagla, science editor of New Delhi television news and author of a book about India’s space efforts, Destination Moon, the country’s public are especially excited about the possibility of beating China to the Red Planet.
If India does beat China to Mars you can imagine the national pride”
Pallava Bagla
Science Editor NDTV
“If India does beat China to Mars you can imagine the national pride,” he told BBC News.
The mission was announced in August last year by India’s Prime Minister Manmohan Singh during his independence day speech, delivered from the ramparts of one of New Delhi’s most iconic buildings – the Red Fort.
“Anything said from the ramparts of the Red Fort is always replete with national pride and national pride is written very largely and boldly on this mission,” according to Mr Bagla.
In 2011, a Chinese attempt to send a spacecraft named Yinghou-1 to Mars was aborted because of a technical problem. The Indian space agency then fast-tracked its Mars mission, called Mangalyaan, readying it in just 15 months.
India has had a space programme for more than 30 years. Until recently, its priority has been to develop technologies that would directly help its poor population, such as improving its telecommunications infrastructure and environmental monitoring with satellites.
Apple SatelliteBut in 2008, ISRO translated its formidable capability to build and launch satellites toward exploration and send a probe to the Moon,Chandrayaan-1. The lunar mission cost more than £55m. Now the government has spent a further £60m to go to Mars.
Poverty
Some have questioned the government’s shift away from building infrastructure towards exploration, and wonder whether the money could have been better spent. It is a point that draws this robust response from Mr Bagla:
“You can’t bring the 400 million people who live in poverty in India out of poverty with this £60 million,” he says.
The shift towards exploration is also a hard-headed one by officials in the hope that it will have clear economic benefits, according to Prof Andrew Coates, who rejoices in the impressive title of “Head of the Solar System” at the Mullard Space Sciences Laboratory in Surrey, part of University College London.
The exploration programme gives them something very high to aim for. They can show the world they have what it takes to send spacecraft to other planets”
Prof Andrew Coates
University College London
“The exploration programme gives them something very high to aim for. If they can show the world they have what it takes to send spacecraft to other planets they can begin to sell launches and space on its launch vehicles to scientific organisations. It also brings India to the table of international space science exploration,” Prof Coates explained.
Developing satellites and developing launchers is now big business. If India, or for that matter China, ease up on their investments in space exploration there is a risk that they could lose out, not least on the vital expertise that this cutting edge endeavour brings to their respective countries.
Big business
Sandeep Chachra, executive director of the poverty eradication charity Action Aid in India believes that investment in space exploration could potentially benefit the country’s poorest.
“Investing in new technology, including space technology is an important part of the aspirations for an economy such as India. Developing a sophisticated technological base in a country with this level of poverty is not a simplistic contradiction ” he told BBC News.
“What is important is to harness the advances that science and technology bring for the greater good and to use those advances to overcome ingrained poverty and build hope for future generations”.
Developing a sophisticated technological base in a country with this level of poverty is not a simplistic contradiction”
Sandeep Chachra
Action Aid in India
China though remains the greater power in space. The China National Space Administration (CNSA) has a well developed astronaut programme and an orbiting laboratory called Tiangong-1. The CNSA is planning to send its Chang’e-3 spacecraft and accompanying rover to the Moon in December.
The mission is part of an ambitious plan to send more robotic probes to the Moon with a view to eventually sending astronauts to the lunar surface.
The Japanese Space Agency (Jaxa) is also a major force in the region. It is by far the most experienced Asian space agency, with numerous unmanned scientific interplanetary missions under its belt.
“India, China and Japan are certainly eyeing each other up,” says Prof Coates.
The growing rivalry is likely to see a new boom in space exploration – one that will eventually lead to more collaborative missions between the emerging space-faring nations in Asia. That might eventually lead to a truly global effort to send astronauts to Mars.
By Pallab Ghosh
BBC WORLD
READ MORE